by Alex Tribick
17 November 2026
Rail operators and transport authorities seem to increasingly be pursuing passengers for Fare Evasion prosecutions when alleged to have travelled without a valid ticket. Cases are usually brought under the Regulation of Railways Act 1889, or the Railway Byelaws 2005 and differing evidential and legal requirements apply to each.
A distinction in fare evasion cases concerns the issue of intent. Under the Regulation of Railways Act, the prosecution should prove beyond reasonable doubt that the defendant intended to avoid payment. Defence practitioners frequently challenge this element by demonstrating honest mistake, confusion regarding ticketing systems, malfunctioning ticket machines, technological failures involving mobile tickets, or genuine misunderstandings arising from complex fare structures. Where intent cannot be established, the prosecution’s case may be significantly weakened.
However, offences under the Railway Byelaws are often regarded as strict liability offences. Defence strategies therefore focus on procedural and evidential issues, including identification of the passenger, compliance with railway enforcement procedures, evidential continuity, and the accuracy of witness statements prepared by the prosecution.
Early engagement is crucial to an effective defence. In many first-time cases, it is possible to seek to avoid prosecution altogether through written representations and negotiated settlements with train operating companies. Such resolutions may involve payment of the unpaid fare, administrative costs, and an agreement that criminal proceedings will not be pursued. This approach is particularly important for professionals concerned about the reputational and employment consequences of a criminal conviction. In particular, regulated professionals can fall foul of the “conduct not befitting” provisions of their profession and often find themselves in a “double bubble” position of being punished twice for the same matter by the courts and then their regulator.
Where proceedings have commenced, defence lawyers scrutinise disclosure, interview notes, body-worn video evidence, and ticketing records. Mitigation may also play a critical role, especially when defendants have no previous offences and can demonstrate genuine error rather than deliberate dishonesty.
For further guidance, or to make an appointment, please get in touch.
Speak with us